(2) In 1 Samuel, sacrifice outside of Jerusalem is treated as an entirely normal thing, and Samuel presides in one such case (
1Sa 9:11-24). In 1Ki the practice of using high places is treated as legitimate before the construction of the Temple (
1Ki 3:2-4), but after that it is condemned unequivocally. The primal sin of Northern Israel was the establishment of high places (
1Ki 12:31-33;
13:2,
33 f), and their continuance was a chief cause of the evils that came to pass (
2Ki 17:10 f), while worship in them was a characteristic of the mongrel throng that repopulated Samaria (
2Ki 17:32). So Judah sinned in building high places
(
1Ki 14:23), but the editor of Kings notes with obvious regret that even the pious kings (Asa,
1Ki 15:14; Jehoshaphat, 22:43; Jehoash,
2Ki 12:3; Amaziah, 14:4; Azariah, 15:4; Jotham, 15:35) did not put them away; i.e. the editor of Kings has about the point of view of
De 12:8-11, according to which sacrifice was not to be restricted to Jerusalem until the country should be at peace, but afterward the restriction should be absolute. The practice had been of such long standing that Hezekiah's destruction of the high places (
2Ki 18:4) could be cited by Rabshakeh as an act of apostasy from Yahweh (
2Ki 18:22;
2Ch 32:12;
Isa 36:7). Under Manasseh they were rebuilt, in connection with other idolatrous practices (
2Ki 21:3-9). This act determined the final punishment of the nation (21:10-15), and the root-and-branch reformation of Josiah (
2Ki 23) came too late. The attitude of the editor of Chronicles is still more condemnatory. He explains the sacrifice at Gibeon as justified by the presence of the Tabernacle (
1Ch 16:39;
21:29;
2Ch 1:3,
13), states that God-fearing northerners avoided the high places (
2Ch 11:16; compare
1Ki 19:10,
14), and (against Kings) credits Asa (
2Ch 14:3,
5) and Jehoshaphat (
2Ch 17:6) with their removal. (This last notice is also in contradiction with
2Ch 20:33, but 16:17a is probably meant to refer to the Northern Kingdom, despite 16:17b.) On the other hand, the construction of high places is added to the sins of Jehoram (
2Ch 21:11) and of Ahaz (
2Ch 28:4,
5).